LegendaryBiographiesBag 0

Free chapter · Legendary Biographies No. 030

from The Bargain, a biography of Orenthal James Simpson

Chapter 1Potrero Hill

by Bernard Pell · 5,644 words · about 24 minutes

Foreword

I have spent my working life writing about men who commanded armies. Generals, marshals, the occasional dictator — men whose decisions could be traced through orders and dispatches, whose failures were measured in divisions lost and cities burned. That was my training at Oxford and my brief education in the Royal Marines before journalism claimed me, and it has been my beat for thirty years. So when I told colleagues I was writing a book about O.J. Simpson, an American running back, the response was uniform and unspoken: this was not my subject. He commanded nothing. He conquered nothing. He carried a ball.

They were wrong, and the ways in which they were wrong became the book.

Because the discipline I practice is not really the study of war. It is the study of how a man acquires power over the way other people see him, how he deploys that power, and what happens when the campaign collapses. By that definition, O.J. Simpson ran one of the most successful campaigns in modern American history. For twenty-five years he made an entire country see exactly what he intended it to see — the smiling athlete, the pitchman in the airport, the man who had transcended everything he came from — and the apparatus of that campaign, once I began to examine it, was as deliberate as any general staff's. The staff work was his own. The terms of engagement were set at a university in Los Angeles in 1967. The collapse, when it came, was watched by more people than have witnessed any battle in human history.

The research was not what I anticipated. I expected to work quickly; the record of this life is enormous and public, and I assumed the size of the archive meant the work had been done. It had not. The trial transcript alone runs past fifty thousand pages. Around it stand the memoirs of the lawyers, the depositions of the civil case, the police records, the press archives of three decades, and the extraordinary documentary record of a life that was conducted, almost from adolescence, in front of cameras. I read the authorized version — the version Simpson himself refined across decades of interviews — and then I read the record underneath it, and the two do not match. The gaps between them are where this book lives. A military historian learns early that the communiqué and the battlefield are different documents. I have never seen the principle demonstrated more completely than here.

What I found underneath was a transaction. Simpson was offered, at every stage of his ascent, a version of the same arrangement: entry into rooms that men from the Potrero Hill housing projects were never meant to enter, in exchange for the permanent suppression of everything those rooms preferred not to see. He did not merely accept the arrangement. He perfected it. He made himself its most brilliant executor, and the country was his willing counterparty, and the question of what the arrangement concealed — and who ultimately paid for the concealment — is the question of his life. Hence the title of this book.

He is worth a book, finally, because his life is the rare case in which a single man's private catastrophe became a full accounting of the society around him: its housing policy and its police force, its courts and its television networks, its hunger for heroes and its arrangements for disposing of them. I have written about wars that revealed less. The armies here were small — at the end, on a June night in 1994, they numbered one — but the terrain they fought over was the entire apparatus by which America decides what it is willing to know.

I came to this subject an outsider, from another country and another discipline. I finish it convinced that the distance was the only useful thing I brought. What follows is not the communiqué. It is my best reconstruction of the battlefield.

— Bernard Pell, Oxford

Chapter 1 · Potrero Hill

The address was in the Potrero Terrace housing projects, on the southeastern slope of San Francisco's Potrero Hill, and the building was public housing.

Not the public housing of political speeches, the abstraction that candidates invoke when they need a backdrop for their bootstrap narratives, but the actual, physical infrastructure of state-managed poverty: a unit in the Potrero Hill housing projects, a cluster of barracks-style buildings erected in 1941 as temporary wartime housing for shipyard workers at the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard, converted after the war into permanent residences for families who could not afford to live anywhere else in a city that was already, in the 1940s and 1950s, pricing out the people whose labor had built it. The buildings were designed to last five years. They lasted forty. The residents were supposed to be transitional. They became permanent. The distinction between temporary and permanent, in the architecture of American poverty, has always been a lie the government tells itself.

Orenthal James Simpson was born there on July 9, 1947, one of four children born to Eunice and Jimmy Lee Simpson. The name Orenthal came from an aunt, who said it was the name of a French or Italian actor she liked — though no researcher has ever located an actor of that era, French, Italian, or otherwise, whose name resembles it. The family called him O.J. from the start; by his own account, he did not learn his given name until a teacher read it aloud in school. The name belonged to him alone, and for the first eighteen years of his life it was among the few things that did.

The family occupied a two-bedroom unit. Eunice and Jimmy Lee shared one bedroom. The four children — Orenthal, his brother Melvin, and his sisters Shirley and Carmelita — shared the other. The projects at Potrero Hill housed approximately three thousand residents in the early 1950s, almost all of them Black families who had migrated to San Francisco during the Second Great Migration, drawn by the promise of shipyard jobs that had largely evaporated by the time the Simpson family was established there. San Francisco's Black population had grown from 4,846 in 1940 to 43,502 in 1950, according to U.S. Census figures — an increase of nearly 800 percent in a single decade, driven almost entirely by the labor demands of wartime industrial production at the Hunters Point and Mare Island naval shipyards. When the war ended, the jobs contracted. The workers remained. The housing projects that had been built to serve a temporary industrial workforce became, by default, the permanent infrastructure of a community that the city had recruited and then abandoned.

Potrero Hill in the early 1950s occupied a specific position in San Francisco's racial geography. It sat on the southeastern slope of the hill that gave it its name, overlooking the industrial flatlands of the Bayview-Hunters Point district — the most heavily Black neighborhood in a city that was, by the standards of the American West, remarkably segregated for its reputation as a progressive bastion. San Francisco's liberalism was a liberalism of the tongue rather than the deed. The city that would later celebrate its commitment to civil rights maintained, throughout the 1940s and 1950s, informal but effective mechanisms of residential segregation that concentrated Black residents in the southeastern quadrant — Bayview-Hunters Point, the Fillmore, and the public housing developments at Potrero Hill and Sunnydale, while preserving the western and northern neighborhoods for white homeowners. The mechanisms were familiar: restrictive covenants written into property deeds, lending practices that denied mortgages to Black applicants regardless of creditworthiness, real estate agents who steered Black families away from white neighborhoods, and a public housing authority that built projects exclusively in areas that were already Black or industrial or both.

The Potrero Hill projects reflected this geography precisely. They were located in an area zoned for industrial use, adjacent to a Southern Pacific rail yard, downwind from a PG&E power plant, and within walking distance of the slaughterhouses and rendering plants that lined the southern waterfront. The air quality, as measured by the San Francisco Department of Public Health in studies conducted decades later, was among the worst in the city. When San Francisco began gathering citywide lead-poisoning data in the 1990s, it found that children living in housing built before 1950 — the category that included the wartime barracks of Potrero Hill — were nearly nine times more likely than other children in the city to show extremely high levels of lead in their blood. The children who grew up there, including O.J. Simpson, were exposed to environmental toxins that would not be publicly documented until long after they had done their damage.

This is not the origin story O.J. Simpson told. In the version he refined over decades of interviews, speeches, and the controlled self-mythology that became his primary occupation after football, the Potrero Hill years were hardscrabble but fundamentally wholesome — a poor but proud Black family, a mother who worked hard, children who played on the streets and found their way to football. The poverty was real in his telling, but it was clean poverty, narrative poverty, the kind that exists to be overcome. The housing projects were a starting line, not a destination. The mother was strong. The football was waiting.

The actual record is more complicated, and the complications matter — not because the mythology of bootstrap ascent is false in its broadest strokes, but because the specific details Simpson omitted from his public narrative reveal the machinery that produced him: the racial engineering of San Francisco's housing policy, the environmental racism that poisoned the ground his family lived on, the absent father whose departure shaped the household, and the gang membership that Simpson spent his adult life denying or minimizing but that multiple contemporaries have confirmed.


Jimmy Lee Simpson was a cook and a custodian. He worked at the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, according to employment records and family accounts corroborated by multiple biographers. He was also, according to neighbors and family members who spoke to journalists and biographers over the years, gay, or bisexual, or involved with men, the terminology varying with the source and the era. The specifics of Jimmy Lee Simpson's sexuality were never confirmed by the man himself in any public statement or known private correspondence. What is confirmed is that he left the family when Orenthal was four or five years old (the exact year varies between 1951 and 1952 depending on the source) and that his departure was, by all accounts, permanent in its emotional dimensions even when it was not absolute in its physical ones.

Jimmy Lee Simpson did not vanish entirely. He lived in San Francisco for the rest of his life. He saw his children intermittently. But the household he left behind was, from 1952 onward, a household run by Eunice Simpson alone, on the wages of an orderly at San Francisco General Hospital. She held the position for decades, working the night shift to be available for her children during the day. The logistics of this arrangement were punishing: she worked from eleven at night until seven in the morning, came home, got the children ready for school, slept when they were in class, and was awake when they returned. The schedule left gaps. The gaps were filled by the street.

O.J. Simpson described his mother, in interviews over the decades, in terms that were simultaneously admiring and evasive. She was strong. She was hardworking. She held the family together. All of this was true and all of it was insufficient, because the description omitted the conditions under which she was strong and hardworking and holding the family together — conditions that included a chronically ill son, a neighborhood functionally abandoned by the city, and the complete absence of the financial and institutional support that might have made the holding-together less heroic and more sustainable.

The chronically ill son was Orenthal himself. Simpson was born with rickets, a condition caused by vitamin D deficiency that results in the softening and weakening of bones, particularly in the legs. In the mid-twentieth-century United States, rickets was disproportionately common among Black children in northern and western cities, a consequence of limited sun exposure, inadequate nutrition, and the dietary deficiencies that accompanied poverty in communities where fresh food was expensive and public health infrastructure was minimal. Simpson's rickets manifested as bowed legs, a visible deformity that required him to wear leg braces and corrective shoes as a young child. The braces were homemade, according to Simpson's own account: Eunice fashioned them from iron bars and straps because she could not afford the medical devices that a doctor had recommended.

The image of O.J. Simpson in leg braces is one of the biographical details that survived into his public mythology, because it served the narrative of overcoming. The child who could barely walk became the man who ran for 2,003 yards in a single NFL season. The iron braces became a metaphor for the obstacles that talent and determination could transcend. What dropped out of the story was the medical context: rickets, in a child born in public housing in 1947, was not a random misfortune but a predictable consequence of the poverty that public housing was designed to contain rather than alleviate. The disease was the environment expressing itself through the body. The braces were the mother's improvisation against a system that had already decided how much her son's health was worth.

Simpson recovered. The rickets resolved as he grew older, either through natural development or through the improved nutrition that Eunice was able to provide as her employment stabilized. The medical records from this period, if they exist, have never been made public. By the time he was eight or nine, according to his own account and the accounts of childhood friends, the bowed legs had straightened and the braces were gone. What remained was an unusual combination: the legs were now straight, but the muscles that had developed around the deformity gave him an unusual gait, a low center of gravity and a lateral quickness that made him, within a decade, one of the most elusive runners in the history of American football. The disease that should have crippled him produced, through the mechanics of compensatory development, the physical foundation of his athletic career. The transformation was not a morality tale. It was a medical fact that happened to have extraordinary consequences.


The street that received O.J. Simpson when his mother was at work and his father was gone was a specific street, and the culture of that street needs to be described precisely because Simpson spent his adult life obscuring it.

Potrero Hill in the late 1950s and early 1960s was organized, as many urban Black neighborhoods were, around informal social structures that ranged from benign to dangerous. The benign end included church communities, extended family networks, and recreational organizations like the Pop Warner football leagues that Simpson would later join. The dangerous end included gangs — not the institutionalized drug-trafficking organizations that the word "gang" would come to denote in the 1980s and 1990s, but neighborhood crews that were primarily territorial, primarily concerned with reputation and local dominance, and primarily composed of teenage boys who had nowhere else to direct their energy and no institutional structure to absorb it.

Simpson was a member of a group called the Persian Warriors. This is not disputed by anyone who grew up with him, though Simpson himself addressed it only rarely and with careful vagueness in his public life. Joe Bell, a childhood friend who remained close to Simpson for decades, confirmed the gang membership in multiple interviews. Al Cowlings, who became Simpson's lifelong best friend and, in 1994, the driver of the most famous vehicle pursuit in American history, was also a member. The Persian Warriors were a Potrero Hill crew, territorial rather than criminal in their primary orientation, though the distinction between territorial and criminal in a housing project where the police were an occupying force rather than a protective service was not one that the members themselves would have recognized. They fought. They stole. They established dominance over their blocks through the threat and occasional application of violence. They were, in the taxonomy of 1950s and 1960s urban youth culture, a gang.

Simpson's involvement was not peripheral. According to Bell and other contemporaries who spoke to Lawrence Schiller for his 1996 book American Tragedy and to other journalists over the years, Simpson was active, present, and engaged: a participant in fights, a presence on the street, a young man whose physical size (he was large for his age) and personal charisma made him a natural figure of influence in the group's hierarchy. He was also, by multiple accounts, reckless: drawn to confrontation, quick to fight, possessed of a temper that became one of the most heavily litigated facts in American legal history.

The recklessness brought him to the attention of authorities. Simpson was arrested more than once as a juvenile, and after one gang fight he was briefly held at the San Francisco Youth Guidance Center. The records are sealed, as juvenile records are in California, but Simpson himself acknowledged the arrests in later interviews, describing them as minor incidents that his mother handled. Other sources have suggested there were multiple encounters with police, most of them informal — stop-and-question interactions that were routine for Black teenagers in public housing in the early 1960s and that left no paper trail because they were not designed to create one. They were designed to establish a relationship between the police and the policed, and the relationship was simple: the police were in charge, and the young men who lived in the projects were, by definition, suspects.

What interrupted the trajectory was the intervention of two forces that operated in sequence: his mother, and football.


Eunice Simpson's intervention has been described, in the authorized version, as a conversation, a stern maternal talk that set the boy straight and pointed him toward a better path. The actual intervention appears to have been more institutional than conversational. According to accounts from family members and contemporaries, the family steered O.J. toward the Booker T. Washington Community Center, where a youth counselor named Lefty Gordon ran programs for teenagers like him. Gordon's programs were not unusual — every Black neighborhood in every American city had some version of them, staffed by volunteers and community members who understood that the gap between the school day and the mother's work shift was the space in which young men were lost, and who tried to fill that gap with structured activity.

But the intervention that mattered most, the one Simpson credited with changing his life in the language of gratitude that athletes use when describing the coaches who saved them, came from an unexpected source. In 1962, when Simpson was in his mid-teens and fresh from a stint at the Youth Guidance Center after a gang fight, word of the talented, troubled teenager reached Willie Mays — through Lefty Gordon and through Simpson's own family — and Mays agreed to spend an afternoon with him.

Willie Mays was, in 1962, the most famous Black athlete in San Francisco and arguably the most famous Black man in the city. He played center field for the San Francisco Giants, who had relocated from New York in 1958, and he lived (this detail matters) in a house in a previously all-white neighborhood on the city's west side that he had been able to purchase only after a public controversy in which the original white homeowner had refused to sell to him because of his race, and the mayor of San Francisco had intervened personally to broker the sale. Mays's presence in that neighborhood was itself a civil rights event, a breach in the residential segregation that the city maintained through informal means, and his willingness to spend time with teenagers from the projects was an act of community investment that was common among Black athletes of his generation and that became, in later decades, rarer as the financial machinery of professional sports separated athletes from the communities that produced them.

The visit was unhurried and almost ordinary — Mays went about his day, and Simpson tagged along — and, according to Simpson's account repeated in numerous interviews over the decades, its message was that he had choices, that athletic ability was a resource, that the projects were not a destiny. The message was not original. It was the standard message that successful Black men delivered to young Black men in housing projects across America, and it worked or it didn't depending on variables that had nothing to do with the message itself: the boy's native talent, the availability of programs, the presence of coaches who could channel raw ability into structured competition, the willingness of schools to invest in athletes who might otherwise be expelled, and, above all, the degree to which the boy wanted to be seen.

O.J. Simpson wanted to be seen. This desire preceded football and outlasted it. It was the animating force of his entire life, the engine that drove him from Potrero Hill to USC to the NFL to Hollywood to the back seat of a white Ford Bronco to a Las Vegas hotel room to a Nevada state prison. Every decision he made, every relationship he entered, every crime he committed or was accused of committing, can be traced to this single, inexhaustible need: to be watched, to be admired, to be the center of the room, to be the person everyone was looking at. The need was not vanity, or not only vanity. It was the survival strategy of a child who had learned, in a household with an absent father and a mother who was gone every night, that attention was the scarcest resource and the only reliable currency.

Football provided the first legitimate arena for this need. The game rewarded exactly what Simpson could offer: speed, elusiveness, the ability to make a crowd watch him and only him, the transformation of individual physical genius into public spectacle. He began playing organized football in the Pop Warner leagues that operated in the Bayview-Hunters Point area, and his talent was immediately apparent. Not gradually apparent, not the kind of talent that emerges through coaching and repetition, but the kind that announces itself the first time the ball is placed in the player's hands. He was fast. He was elusive. He had the low center of gravity that the rickets and the compensatory muscle development had given him, and he had the peripheral vision and the instinct for open space that cannot be taught.

He played for Galileo High School, on the northern edge of San Francisco. Still within the orbit of the projects, still in the geography of Black San Francisco, but a step removed from Potrero Hill itself. At Galileo, he played both football and track, and in both sports his dominance was immediate. He was a sprinter as well as a runner — he would eventually post a 9.4-second 100-yard dash and run a leg on a world-record USC relay team. On the football field, he was the best player anyone at the school had ever seen, and this was not hyperbole: coaches, opponents, and teammates who were interviewed decades later uniformly confirmed that Simpson's talent at Galileo was of a different order than anything they had encountered.

But his grades were poor. This was the bottleneck that nearly derailed the trajectory, the point at which the bootstrap narrative almost collapsed under the weight of a fact that the narrative could not accommodate: O.J. Simpson was a poor student, not because he lacked intelligence but because the educational infrastructure available to him was inadequate and because his priorities were elsewhere. The Potrero Hill schools he had attended before Galileo were underfunded, overcrowded, and staffed by teachers who were themselves products of a system that did not invest in the education of Black children in public housing. The foundational skills that Simpson did not acquire in those schools (the reading comprehension, the mathematical fluency, the study habits) were not deficits he could overcome through athletic talent, and no major four-year university was willing to offer him a scholarship with his academic record.

The solution was City College of San Francisco, a two-year community college that served, in the 1960s as it does today, as a bridge between the students that the educational system had failed and the institutions that required evidence of academic competence before they would extend their resources. Simpson enrolled at City College in the fall of 1965, and what happened there was the first demonstration of a pattern that defined his entire public life: the system bent for him because his talent was too valuable to waste, and the bending was presented as opportunity rather than as the preferential treatment it also was.

At City College, Simpson was a sensation. He rushed for 2,552 yards in two seasons, scored 54 touchdowns, and established himself as the most prolific runner in junior-college football. He led the school to a Prune Bowl championship over Long Beach City College in 1966 and was named a junior-college All-American. His performance was so dominant that it attracted the attention of every major college football program in the country, and the academic deficiencies that had barred him from those programs two years earlier were, in the light of 2,552 yards and 54 touchdowns, suddenly manageable. The grades were not better. The system's willingness to accommodate the grades was.

He chose the University of Southern California. The choice was significant in ways that extended beyond football, because USC was not just a football program — it was a social network, a brand, an identity, a machine for converting athletic talent into cultural capital. USC's football program in the late 1960s, under head coach John McKay, was the most prestigious in the country, and its alumni network extended into the entertainment industry, the legal profession, real estate, and the corporate boardrooms of Southern California. To play football at USC was to be adopted by an institution that would continue to serve you long after your eligibility expired — provided you played the game correctly, and the game was not only football.

The game was assimilation. USC in 1967 was a predominantly white, wealthy, conservative institution that recruited Black athletes to play football and basketball and expected those athletes to be grateful, compliant, and, above all, nonthreatening to the white donors and alumni whose money sustained the program. The expectation was not spoken. It did not need to be. It was communicated through a thousand small signals: the way coaches spoke to Black players versus white players, the social events to which Black athletes were and were not invited, the neighborhoods where they were and were not welcome, the women they were and were not supposed to pursue. The message was clear: your talent has purchased your admission to this world, but the price of remaining in it is the suppression of anything that might remind the people around you that you come from a place they would never visit and a life they would never live.

O.J. Simpson did not resist this bargain. He embraced it. He did not simply accept the terms of admission to white America — he internalized them, perfected them, and built his entire post-football career on the principle that a Black man could succeed in America by being so charming, so unthreatening, so willing to laugh at the right jokes and stand in the right rooms and never, under any circumstances, remind white people that race existed as a category that might implicate them in anything uncomfortable. This was the strategy. It worked brilliantly for twenty-five years. It failed catastrophically on June 12, 1994.

But in 1967, the failure was a quarter-century away, and the strategy was just beginning.


Most biographies of O.J. Simpson begin at USC, or at the Heisman ceremony, or at City College, at the moment when the talent became visible and the trajectory became legible. The Potrero Hill years are treated as prelude, as the dark matter before the big bang, as the undifferentiated background from which the figure emerged. This treatment serves the narrative that Simpson himself spent his adult life constructing: the narrative of transcendence, of a man who rose above his circumstances through talent and charm and the peculiarly American magic of being so good at something that the country had to let you in.

But the Potrero Hill years were not prelude. They were foundation. The absent father produced the bottomless need for attention and approval that drove Simpson to be the most visible man in every room he entered for the rest of his life. The housing projects produced the understanding that escape was possible only through performance — that you had to be so good, so entertaining, so useful to the people who controlled access to the world outside the projects, that they would open the gate and let you through. The gang membership produced the comfort with violence and the belief that physical dominance was a legitimate form of social currency. The poverty produced the hunger for wealth that made Simpson susceptible to the Las Vegas scheme that finally imprisoned him. The mother's night-shift absences produced the self-reliance and the loneliness. The rickets produced the legs. The legs produced the career.

Everything that O.J. Simpson became was assembled in those first eighteen years on Potrero Hill and in the schools and streets and football fields of southeastern San Francisco. The machinery of his life was built there, and it ran on the fuel that was loaded there, and when it finally broke down — when the charm failed and the violence surfaced and the nation watched a white Ford Bronco crawl down a Los Angeles freeway with a fugitive in the back seat — the breakdown was not a malfunction. It was the machinery operating exactly as it had been built to operate, in circumstances that no longer rewarded what it produced.

The boy from the projects became the man on trial. The man on trial became the man in prison. The man in prison became the man who died of cancer in Las Vegas, Nevada, on April 10, 2024, at the age of seventy-six. The distance between the Potrero Hill projects and the Las Vegas house where Simpson died is approximately 570 miles by road. The distance between the boy in the leg braces and the old man in the hospital bed is the subject of this book.


### Notes

Sources for Chapter 1:

The demographic and housing data for Potrero Hill and San Francisco's Black community are drawn from U.S. Census records (1940, 1950, 1960) and from Albert Broussard's Black San Francisco: The Struggle for Racial Equality in the West, 1900-1954 (University Press of Kansas, 1993), which remains the definitive study of the Great Migration's impact on San Francisco.

Simpson's birth date, family composition, and early childhood are documented in multiple biographies, most comprehensively in Lawrence Schiller and James Willwerth's American Tragedy: The Uncensored Story of the Simpson Defense (Random House, 1996) and in Sheila Weller's Raging Heart: The Intimate Story of the Tragic Marriage of O.J. and Nicole Brown Simpson (Pocket Books, 1995). Simpson's own accounts of his childhood appear in numerous interviews, including his extended conversation with journalist Robert Lipsyte for The New York Times (1968) and in the documentary O.J.: Made in America (ESPN Films, 2016), directed by Ezra Edelman.

The description of Potrero Hill's environmental conditions draws on the citywide childhood lead-poisoning data that San Francisco began gathering in the 1990s — which found children living in pre-1950 housing nearly nine times more likely than other children to show extremely high blood lead levels — and on subsequent reporting on childhood lead exposure in the city's southeastern neighborhoods.

Jimmy Lee Simpson's departure from the family and the circumstances surrounding it are discussed in Schiller and Willwerth, in Weller, and in the Edelman documentary, which includes interviews with family members and childhood acquaintances. The question of Jimmy Lee Simpson's sexuality was first reported by Schiller and has been addressed in subsequent accounts; this biography relies on the accounts of neighbors and family members as reported by multiple independent journalists and does not make claims beyond what those sources support.

Simpson's rickets and leg braces are described in his own public statements and confirmed by childhood acquaintances. The medical context — the prevalence of rickets among Black children in mid-century urban America — is drawn from public health literature of the period, including studies published by the American Academy of Pediatrics.

The Persian Warriors gang membership is confirmed by Joe Bell and Al Cowlings in interviews conducted by multiple journalists over several decades. Simpson's own acknowledgment of gang involvement is sparse but present in the historical record.

The Willie Mays visit — arranged through Lefty Gordon, the youth counselor at the Booker T. Washington Community Center — is described by Simpson in multiple interviews and is corroborated by contemporaries, including in Sports Illustrated's retrospective account (May 11, 1987). Mays's difficulty purchasing a home in the Sherwood Forest neighborhood is documented in the San Francisco Chronicle archives (1957) and in James Hirsch's biography Willie Mays: The Life, The Legend (Scribner, 2010).

Simpson's academic record and the pathway through City College of San Francisco to USC are documented in Schiller, in the Edelman documentary, and in USC's own athletic records. His rushing statistics at City College and USC are a matter of public record maintained by the respective institutions and by the NCAA.

The Heisman Trophy statistics are maintained by the Heisman Trust.